← All insights

Retained vs Contingency: Which Fits a COO Hire

For a COO or President hire at an owner-led company, a retained search is usually the better fit, because the firm is engaged exclusively, the fee is set upfront, and the work includes assessment and a written replacement guarantee. Contingency recruiting can still fit mid-level or well-defined functional seats, and this page explains the difference.

Retained vs contingency: which fits a COO hire

For a COO, President, Integrator, or VP at an owner-led or PE-backed company, a retained search is usually the better fit. You engage one firm to complete that search. The fee is agreed before work starts. The work covers confidential outreach, a structured assessment, and a written replacement guarantee.

That kind of seat carries real operating weight. The leader you want is often already succeeding somewhere else and is not posting a resume. A retained executive search firm is hired to reach those people, learn your business first, and present a short list you can stand behind.

Captains Club Talent LLC, based in Gilbert, Arizona, serves owners throughout the Western U.S. with retained executive search. Daniel Cheetham, the founder, leads each search through the signed offer.

How the two models compare

Who pays, and when. In contingency recruiting, you pay a fee only after you hire someone the firm introduced. In a retained search, you hire the firm to run the search itself, and you pay as that work is done.

Whether the engagement is exclusive. Contingency openings are often shared across firms, and a candidate may be sent to more than one employer at the same time. A retained search is exclusive. One firm runs the process until the seat is filled.

How candidates are found and assessed. Contingency recruiting often starts with posted roles and people who are already applying. A retained search maps where the right operators sit, approaches them directly, and tests operating fit, values, and leadership style before you see a short list.

What happens if the search fails, or the hire does not work out. If a contingency search does not produce a hire, you typically do not pay a placement fee. You also may have little exclusive effort behind the search, and guarantee terms, if any, vary by firm. Retained firms set their own replacement terms in writing. At Captains Club, the home page states: "Every placement carries a six-month replacement guarantee. If it doesn't work out, we pick up where we left off to ensure the right candidate is in place. Our job isn't done at the offer letter."

How fees are set. Many firms set the fee as a share of the new leader's pay, so the invoice rises if the offer rises. In a 2016 SHRM article by Mark Feffer, the typical fee is described as about 33 percent of first-year cash compensation, counting salary plus bonus and any signing bonus. Some retained firms also use a percentage. Captains Club uses a flat fee. Current pricing is on What we do: "One flat fee, set upfront. Most searches fall between $45,000 and $75,000."

How a retained executive search works

A retained executive search starts with a strategy session. Before outreach begins, the firm learns how your leadership team works, gets agreement on the seat, and writes a scorecard, a target profile, and a compensation range. Candidates who move forward see a private briefing on the company, the mission, and what success in the seat looks like.

Outreach is confidential and aimed at leaders who are already doing similar work. Finalists are assessed with Navigating Talent. Head covers how they think and how they will work with your team. Heart covers values and motivation. Helm covers a proven operating record. Horizon gets a light look when the seat depends on the relationships a leader can bring. You receive a written profile on each finalist, with risks, trade-offs, and a recommendation.

The firm stays involved through the offer, pay conversations, and a 90-day onboarding plan. The engagement also includes the six-month replacement guarantee described above.

On the Results page, Captains Club reports a 94% 12-month stick rate, together with a 9.6 Net Promoter Score.

When contingency recruiting can still fit

Contingency recruiting can be a sound choice for a mid-level or functional seat, for example a sales manager, a project lead, or a plant controller, when the skill set is clear and plenty of qualified people are already looking. In those cases, speed and a wide active pool may matter more than a long exclusive engagement.

For a COO or President hire, and for a VP or Integrator who will help set the company's direction, a retained search is usually the better investment. The seat is harder to specify up front, the best people are often not looking, and the cost of a miss shows up in lost time, a second search, and work that stalls. For President seats, see President executive search.

How Captains Club prices a retained search

On What we do, the fee is stated this way: "One flat fee, set upfront. Most searches fall between $45,000 and $75,000."

"Every search starts with a $5,000 monthly retainer, and every dollar is credited toward one flat search fee."

The home page also states the six-month replacement guarantee quoted earlier. Use the What we do page for current figures if they are ever updated. For a full breakdown, see what executive search costs for a COO or President.

Retained vs contingency FAQs

Retained vs contingency executive search: which is better for hiring a COO?

For a COO hire at an owner-led company, a retained search is usually the better fit, because the firm is engaged exclusively, the fee is set upfront, and the work includes assessment and a written replacement guarantee. Contingency recruiting can still fit mid-level or well-defined functional seats with a large active candidate pool.

What does a retained search mean?

A retained search is an exclusive engagement. You hire a firm to run the search for a specific leadership seat, and that firm is paid to complete the work. At Captains Club, every search starts with a $5,000 monthly retainer credited dollar-for-dollar toward one flat fee, typically $45,000 to $75,000, set before the search begins.

What is a retained executive search firm?

A retained executive search firm accepts exclusive search engagements for senior leadership seats, such as COO, President, CEO, Integrator, or VP roles. Captains Club operates from Gilbert, Arizona, as a retained firm for Arizona owners and others across the Western U.S.

How much does a Captains Club retained search cost?

Captains Club charges one flat fee, typically $45,000 to $75,000, set before the search begins. Every search starts with a $5,000 monthly retainer credited dollar-for-dollar toward that fee, and every placement carries a six-month replacement guarantee. Current pricing is published at https://www.captainsclub.com/what-we-do.

What does Captains Club do if a placement does not work out?

Every placement carries a six-month replacement guarantee. If it doesn't work out, we pick up where we left off to ensure the right candidate is in place. Our job isn't done at the offer letter.

When does contingency recruiting still fit?

Contingency recruiting can fit mid-level or functional seats, such as a sales manager, project manager, or controller, when the skills are well defined and a large active candidate pool already exists. For a COO, President, VP, or Integrator who will shape the next chapter of the company, a retained search is usually the better investment.

Talk through a COO or President hire

If you are weighing retained vs contingency for a COO or President hire, we can discuss the role and which model fits, then you can decide. To compare firms first, read how to choose an executive search firm.

Phone 480-347-9000, or request a conversation on the contact page. Email info@captainsclub.com.

Daniel Cheetham founded Captains Club, which is based in Gilbert, Arizona and serves the Western U.S. He leads retained COO, President, and Integrator searches for owner-operated and PE-backed businesses. The firm reports a 94% 12-month stick rate. More about Captains Club.

About the author

Daniel Cheetham is the founder of Captains Club, a retained executive search firm in Gilbert, Arizona that places COOs, Presidents, and Integrators in owner-operated and PE-backed businesses, with a 94% twelve-month stick rate. More about Captains Club

Weighing a COO, President, or Integrator hire?

Book a confidential conversation. We'll help you define the seat before you search.